Career Ferrata: The perfect Candidate

'Can he do the job?' and 'Do we click?' are the wrong questions. The better one: Does this person close the gap our team actually has? Why the perfect candidate on paper can still be a mis-hire, and why hiring someone like yourself doesn't solve it.

  • The Recruitment Team

Career Ferrata: The perfect candidate

 

Why the CV can’t answer the question that matters most

The background checks out. The skillset is exactly what the role calls for. The experience goes beyond what was asked. On paper, this candidate isn’t just an option; he’s the obvious choice.

The client agrees. The contract is signed. A few months later, it’s clear to everyone that it isn’t working. Not because of what he is missing in the skillset, but because of how he is. The way he communicates, how he handles responsibility, his temperament: none of it works with this team or the company’s culture.

Anyone who’s spent enough time in recruitment has seen this happen. So have we. It’s the story nobody in our industry likes to tell, and the one that teaches you the most.

 

Nobody missed anything

The frustrating part is that there was no red flag anyone overlooked. No gaps in the CV, no job hopping, nothing unusual. The CV couldn’t show what the candidate was missing.

Hard skills tell you whether someone can do the job. They don’t tell you whether someone can do the job at your company, with your team, your leadership culture, and at your pace.

You can always find a good Java engineer. Finding one who also fits your company and genuinely feels welcome there, that’s a different challenge altogether. And that’s what ultimately makes or breaks a permanent hire. In most cases, soft skills carry at least as much weight as hard skills.

 

The second trap: hiring yourself

The obvious fix would be to pay more attention to personality. But that’s where a second, more subtle trap is waiting, one we see all the time in our work.

When people screen for personality, they instinctively gravitate toward what feels familiar. The candidate who communicates the way you do, thinks the way you do, makes decisions the way you do, that person just feels right in the interview. The chemistry is immediate. And the relationship with the manager will probably work out fine.

The problem is that the team had a gap, and it’s still there. If a team is missing its structured voice, its calming influence, its critical thinker, hiring another version of the manager won’t fix that. You’ve brought in someone you get along with, just not the person the team was missing.

There’s a related pattern. Whoever opens a position usually has a competence profile in mind from day one, technically precise, well thought through, complete. Soft skills get treated as something that will sort themselves out. The result: a candidate who matches the profile perfectly, while the very traits the team actually needed never made it into the brief.

Catching either of these from the inside is nearly impossible. It takes an outside perspective, someone who isn’t part of the dynamic and can see what the team is missing.

 

What this means for you

For companies: Even when a candidate looks perfect on paper or instantly feels familiar in the interview, the search isn’t over yet. The question that matters isn’t “Can he do it?” or “Do we click?” It’s: “Does this person close the gap our team actually has?” If you ask it after the signature, you might end up paying the highest price in hiring: a mis-hire.

For candidates: the same logic works in reverse. A company that looks like a perfect match for your profile can turn out to be the wrong place to work. Ask about how they make decisions. How do they handle mistakes? Who held this role before you, and why is the vacancy open?

 

We fill positions in IT and Finance, looking at the whole person, not just the CV.

Open Jobs

Browse the other job openings at Nordwand Group.

Nordwand Group

What sets us apart

We are a leading Swiss IT and finance talent acquisition partner, with a focus on senior and executive hires. Our goal is to help businesses achieve extraordinary outcomes by introducing them to the best talent in the Swiss market.

At Nordwand, we believe in our mission.

As our “north face” name suggests, we draw inspiration from stories of brave alpinists and explorers who made history conquering some of the most challenging, yet coveted, routes to the summit.

The North Face symbolises courage, determination, and the drive for excellence. We draw inspiration from the remarkable achievements of those mountaineers who made alpine history by conquering the most challenging and sought-after routes. Their pioneering spirit and unwavering resolve serve as guiding principles for our daily work.

Just as alpinists forge new paths to the summit, we support companies and candidates on their journey to success - relying on clear strategies, perseverance, and a genuine passion for excellence.